Who goes first?
Updated: Nov 3
Naked and held.
On Monday evening, I held my first Soul Circle, a sharing circle loosely inspired by twelve-step support meetings.
What every person brought to the circle is exactly what touches and inspires me deeply in this work. We all feel so disconnected. We are simply looking to feel a bit less alone, less isolated. And very little already seems to be enough. Time spent together, a space where we feel respected, seen and heard.
We struggle to find the room, the time, the energy, the courage to connect with each other, to take what feels like a risk. Each other's masks overwhelm us, and so do our overloaded lives, sometimes harshness, and the climate of fear that rules our society. Fear of the stranger, of differences, of the unknown.
How strange. So many of us feel this disconnection, and each of us feels it alone.
The cost of our masks
One of the most beautiful moments came from a participant who expressed how highly sensitive they are to the presence of others. In a group, they pick up so much from everyone, emotions, energy, information, that it quickly becomes overwhelming and exhausting. Then someone opened up, and they felt something dissolve within them. They no longer needed to protect themselves: the overflow that had been flooding them became connection.
We hold a certain idea of ourselves. But what is left of it when it meets others? I then wondered how much our masks cost us, and those around us.
A study by the psychologists Emily Butler and James Gross offers a glimpse of this. Women who had never met were paired up to watch an upsetting film, then talk about it. In some pairs, one of the two was asked to suppress her emotions: nothing on her face, in her voice, in her gestures. The two women found it harder to connect, and showed less desire to get to know each other. On a physiological level, the woman who was not hiding her emotions saw her blood pressure rise. As if her body was responding to what she could not see.
Hiding has a high energetic cost. Perceiving the other as a possible threat keeps the body on alert, and wears it out.
But when one person sets their mask down, the whole room can start to breathe again.
Easier with strangers
Opening our hearts gives others the courage to do the same. Like skin to skin, a newborn's first bond of safety with the world, heart to heart is a sacred invitation to enter into a dance with the depths of humanity, to find our similarities, to welcome our differences, and to feel seen for who we are, in our imperfection and our dissonances, in our wholeness, raw, without fear of rejection or correction.
And yet, it is sometimes easier to open up to strangers. They don't know the role we play at home, the person we are supposed to be in the eyes of the world. There is a relief in that. No identity to defend or protect, no self-image to polish and maintain.
Why is it so hard to meet each other this way in everyday life?
We are hyperconnected, but isolated. Afraid to meet someone's gaze, to expose ourselves, after building layers and layers of protection against being hurt, humiliated and disrespected by others, who were in turn hurt, humiliated and disrespected by others.
Everything seems within reach, and yet our deepest desire feels out of reach: to feel truly in touch with one another, without fear, without needing to control or to protect our hearts. Without feeling drained by the roles we have taken on, often without choosing them. Out of loyalty to beliefs inherited from families of another era, outrun by a world that moves so fast, and from a society that no longer knows how to offer safe spaces to its members.
A silence that allows
Many of our masks are shaped early, at home. Boris Cyrulnik, known for his work on resilience, describes how a parent's silence passes on anxiety: the child senses that something is missing from the family story, cannot picture what it is, and wonders why the parents keep quiet. For Cyrulnik, life can flow again when a story can finally be shared, and someone is there to hear it. There is a silence that hides, and a silence that allows. In a circle, silence takes on the quality of a nourishing presence, like a hand holding a wounded child's, and frees what the first silence kept in chains.
At the end of the circle, everyone thanked me for the safety they had found there. I was surprised to hear that word from them. And at the same time, deeply touched. They had found exactly what I too am looking for, deep inside. For me, it is the search of a lifetime: for safety in my own body, with those closest to me, in a society I struggle to share values, ideals and aspirations with.
As for me, I felt I had done so little. Simone Weil wrote: "Attention is the rarest and purest form of generosity." Perhaps that attention is already enough.
Generosity as connection
What is generosity, beyond the material frame we usually give it? In our relationships, it can be an act of forgiveness, of patience with others' limitations. Being the first to reach out after a disagreement. Welcoming someone's fears and carrying them with love, because in that moment we happen to feel stronger. Seeing the person as they are, and not as a project to work on. Letting them be, and giving them the courage to recognise the beauty we already see in them, before they can perceive it themselves.
The same generosity is needed towards ourselves, yet it is so often missing. I notice it is always easier for me to feel connected when I feel good in my body. So I came to think that truly connecting also asks us to let ourselves be seen in our imperfect states. In grief, in heaviness, as much as in lightness, excitement and overflowing joy. Without any of it being judged too much, not enough, or out of place. That one is hard for me. Lifting the censorship we were raised with, spilling over the narrow frame drawn for us, which we have served so obediently.
... recognise the beauty we already see in them, before they can perceive it themselves.
So who goes first?
So how do we change the world?
How do we gather the stones again, to lay the foundations of a connected society, one where trust can take the place of fear?
This circle shows me once again: through the power of vulnerability. By exposing ourselves, with open hearts, daring to move towards one another, with transparency and curiosity. It is, of course, easier said than done. So who goes first? We can find this courage together. No one has to look for it alone.
Seeds of love,
♡ Sonia
Sources: Emily Butler, James Gross et al., "The Social Consequences of Expressive Suppression", Emotion, 2003. Boris Cyrulnik, interview with Le Journal de l'Université de Genève, December 2021, and Un merveilleux malheur, Odile Jacob, 1999. Simone Weil, letter to Joë Bousquet, 13 April 1942, Correspondance, L'Âge d'Homme, 1982.
This letter is part of Clair · Obscur, my letters on Substack. To receive the next ones by email:

Comments